.NET vs JAVA in 2023, which one to choose?

When it comes to developing software, .Net & Java are two of the most popular technologies. Both are used to build enterprise-level applications. First released in 2002, .net is a Microsoft framework whereas, Java is being around since mid-1990 and it is an open-source language. While both technologies have their unique features & capabilities. They are often compared and evaluated based on various factors such as scalability, performance, ease of use, community, and platform compatibilities.

Because both .NET and Java can be used to achieve the same development goals, there is often a misunderstanding about which technology is which. While both Java and.NET are frequently referred to as frameworks, only.NET is a framework in the strictest sense. The ASP.NET web application framework is used by the.NET platform to allow developers to construct online apps.

But before diving into the key distinction between Java and .NET, let’s look at the overview of both technologies.

What is .NET vs Java?

Let’s start with understanding the basics of .NET vs java

What is .NET?

.NET is a Microsoft open-source framework aimed towards Microsoft users. The framework was designed specifically for Microsoft when it was initially released in 2002. This implies you won’t code or execute produced apps on Linux, Android, or iOS. It was also a closed-source system.

In 2016, Microsoft released .NET Core, which shifted the framework’s market position. Today, .NET 5 (formerly known as .NET Core) is the most popular framework since it is free of the limitations of earlier windows-only frameworks. .NET 5 has been successfully used to construct projects of varying levels of complexity.

.NET has first launched 19 years ago and is still quite popular; according to the StackOverflow Developer survey, it is the most popular framework and library in the other frameworks and libraries division, with 34.55 percent of the vote.

This framework supports C#, C++, F#, and more programming languages. And adheres to an object-oriented approach. Padigram .NET also includes the Common Language Runtime, which allows you to run compiled source code.

Features of .NET

Pros and Cons of .NET

Pros of .NET

Cons of .NET

What is Java?

Java is a cross-platform, general-purpose, class-based, and object-oriented programming language. Even though Java was introduced 26 years ago, it is still popular, ranking 6th in the StackOverflow developer survey with 33.27 percent.

Java is a fascinating language to work with. You develop a program, which is subsequently compiled to bytecode and converted by the JVM to meet the needs of various devices. There are three versions of Java:

• Java EE (Enterprise Edition)
• Java SE (Standard Edition)
• Java ME (Micro Edition)

As a result, a skilled java developer simply needs to write one code for all platforms.

Java is utilized in every industry you can think of, including eCommerce, IoT, finance, and big data, but it hasn’t yet achieved its peak in that field. CLU, Simula67, Lisp, Smalltalk, Ada, C++, C#, Eiffel, Mesa, Modula-3, Oberon, Objective-C, UCSD Pascal, Object Pascal were all influences on Java. Ada 2005, BeanShell, C#, Chapel, Clojure, ECMAScript, Fantom, Gambas, Groovy, Hack, Haxe, J#, Kotlin, PHP, Python, Scala, Seed7, Vala, JavaScript, JS++.

Features of Java

Pros and Cons of Java

Pros ­of Java

Cons of Java

Head-to-Head Comparison Between .Net and Java:

Key comparisons between .Net vs Java

As with any technology, there are going to be some differences when compared to others and .net and java are no different. Following are a few of the critical differences between .net and java. For better understanding, we have divided these differences into technical and non-technical comparisons.

Technical Comparison

Following is a few of the technical comparison that you should keep in mind while you are deciding which one to choose between java vs .net. Let’s kick start this comparison by comparing the performance of both technologies.

.Net Vs Java: Performance

When it comes to performance, java’s syntax is developed from c and c++. Therefore the two languages have a lot in common. On the other hand, Java is platform-agnostic, meaning that its code can be run on any platform.

 .NET, on the other hand, provides a general-purpose and straightforward programming language that includes type checking, array bounds, garbage collection, and uninitialized variable checks. This increases the endurance, robustness, and efficiency of your system. Only the features of unchecked and checked expectations are arrayed in Java.

.NET vs JAVA: Operating System

One of the most significant differences between Java and .NET is that JAVA, through its compiler and JRE, can operate on any operating system, as it adheres to the “write once, execute anywhere” approach. .NET, on the other hand, is limited to Windows and its various versions. Although there are a few open-source versions of .NET, they all cater to Windows users. Java’s code can run on any platform, thanks to the JVM. Java has a significant advantage over .NET since it is platform-independent and portable.

.NET vs JAVA: Integrated Development Environment

The Java IDE comprises three parts: a code editor, a compiler, and a debugger. Eclipse, Intellij Idea, Oracle NetBeans, and, in addition, an Oracle Jdeveloper that is specifically developed for this purpose makes writing and testing code easier. These IDEs include built-in plugins and auto-fill options, which can increase java’s versatility while also providing opportunities for creativity.

The .NET platform, on the other hand, comes with Visual Studio, which aids in the editing, building, and running customization of API behavior through the use of library macros. Apart from that, developers do not need to test IDEs and other tools ahead of time.

Java vs Dotnet: Support for Languages

One of the essential aspects of Java is that it uses a single language for all platforms. Nonetheless, the software may run on a variety of operating systems. Python, Ruby, Groovy, Scala, and Kotlin are all supported by Java.

The .NET framework, on the other hand, can support backend languages like C# and C++. It currently supports over 20 languages. This allows you to program in any programming language of your choice, including VB.NET, C#,.NET, Perl, and many others. It is, nevertheless, quite handy for producing specific code for the Windows platform only.

As a result, it is possible to conclude that. However, .NET provides a multi-programming environment but supports a single platform, whereas java is based on a single programming language that supports various environments.

Dotnet vs java: Speed of Coding

Although Java has different threads to make handling and processing sequences of instructions easier, .NET remain the leader in terms of coding speed. Because .NET is an object-oriented technology with reusable components, producing the same software in .NET takes less time than designing the same app in Java.

.NET Vs JAVA: Scalability

After the application is fully deployed, both technologies are among the most stable. As a result, both JAVA and .NET are frequently employed for the creation of complex enterprise-level applications.

.NET Vs JAVA: Learning Curve

Both .NET vs JAVA are easy to learn. But if compared, it can be a little overwhelming to learn Java given the length of the documentation, whereas learning .NET is comparatively simple.

.NET vs JAVA: Syntax

Following are the syntax of .NET and JAVA

.NET Syntax

using system;
namespace NAMESPACE_NAME
{
     class Program
     {
           static void Main(string[] args)
           {
                 Console.WriteLine("Content_you-want_to_display");
           }
     }
}

Java Syntax

public class class_name 
{
     public static void main(String[ ] args) 
     {
          System.out.println("Content_you-want_to_display");
     }
}

.NET vs JAVA: Security

In terms of comparing security, both technologies are secure. They support code signing and enforce an execution sandbox. Java is platform-agnostic, so the chances of security breaches are pretty high can be the reason for significant concern. Whereas, .NET provides more security than compared to java.

.NET vs JAVA: Example

The following are the examples for .NET vs JAVA.

.NET

using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;
using System.Threading.Tasks;
namespace ConsoleApp1
{
    class Program
    {
        static void Main(string[] args)
        {
             Console.WriteLine("Hello, world!");
             Console.ReadLine();
        }
   }
}

Java

/* This is a simple Java program.
FileName : "HelloWorld.java". */
public class HelloWorld 
{
     //Your program begins by calling the main().
     //Prints "Hello, World" to the terminal window.
     public static void main(String args[]) 
     {
          System.out.println("Hello World");
     }
}

.NET vs. JAVA: Licensing

.NET is a free, open-source platform with no licensing fees and free development tools for Linux, Windows, and macOS. There is no cost for compilers, libraries, and programming languages as open-source programming languages. There are no licensing fees for commercial use.

Whereas in Java, since the April 2019 java upgrade Java 8,9,10,11,14 are free for personal use and development. Any other use necessitates the purchase of a Commercial License. For Java SE, the subscription following are the products.

Oracle Java SE Desktop Subscription (On-Premises)

• 1 Year Term Subscription combines Java SE Licensing and Support for use on Desktop deployments.
• £23.96

Oracle Java SE Subscription (On-Premises)

• 1 Year Term Subscription combines Java SE Licensing and Support for use on Desktops, Servers, or Cloud deployments.
• £215.65 – £239.61

Oracle Java Development Tools Support (On-Premises)

• Support for NetBeans, Oracle JDeveloper, and Oracle Enterprise Pack for Eclipse.
• £958.44

Also Read: .Net Core Best Practices – Every .Net Developer Must Know

Non-Technical Comparision

Following are some of the non-technical comparisions between .Net and Java. Let’s start with popularity.

.NET vs JAVA: Market Overview & Popularity

Popularity is one of the key non-technical features that should be kept in mind while comparing technologies. Here we have compared .NET vs JAVA regarding Google trends and Stackoverflow developer survey 2022. Let’s look at StackOverflow Developer Survey and Google Trends to discover the popularity of .NET vs. Java.

 Google Trends

In Google trends, we can see the number of queries asked in the last 5 years. It can be seen that  as of 03 March 2023, there is an average of 71 queries for java and 7 for. NET. Here you can see that the blue is specified to java whereas red represents .NET.

StackOver Flow

The below-mentioned graph gives an insight into the number of queries asked on the StackOverflow regarding both technologies. Here Orange represents Java whereas blue is used to represent .NET .

.NET vs JAVA: Time-to-market

The size of your project has a significant impact on this attribute. Your time-to-market for developing a product can be greatly sped up by elements like readily accessible libraries, well-documented technologies, third-party APIs, and a sufficient pool of qualified developers. Everything that makes it possible for you to prevent writing new code from the beginning can be helpful in general. Java and. NET virtually identically matches the necessary code integration and reusability

.NET vs JAVA: Marketshare

According to SimilarTech, .Net powers 1,493,706 webistes, whereas Java supports 58,021 websites.

Marketshare by Top Websites

We can see above that ASP.NET is represented in blue, and Java is represented in Yellow. As you can see below, ASP.NET is leading in the Top 10k sites with 5.56%, the Top 100k sites with 7.063%, the Top 1M sites with 6.968%, and the Entire web with 2.135%. Whereas Java is lacking far behind in all segments. The Top 10k sites with 0.72%, the Top 100k sites with 0.453%, the Top 1M sites with 0.235%, and the Entire web with 0.083%.

 

.NET vs Java: Salary (As per talent)

The average income for a .NET Software Developer / Programmer in the United States is $110,095. The minimum salary is $68,792 and the Maximum salary is $176,199.

• Junior .NET developer – $38.32/per hour /yr
• Intermediate .NET Developer- $61.32/per hour/yr
• Senior .NET developer- $98.14 /per hour/yr

The average income for a Java Software Developer / Programmer in the United States is $109,965. The minimum salary is $73,345 and the Maximum salary is $164,868.

• Junior Java Developer: $47.02/per hour /yr
• Intermediate Java Developer: $70.50/per hour
• Senior Java Developer: $106/per hour

.NET vs Java: Salary (As per LinkedIn)

According to LinkedIn, there are 72,446 results for .net developers, whereas, for Java Developers, there are 132,167 results.

JAVA Vs .NET: Usage Statistics

The following are the usage statistics of .NET vs JAVA according to the w3Tech.

This diagram shows that:

• ASP.NET is used by 7.2% of all the server-side programming language
• ASP.NET is used by 9.7% of all the server-side programming languages we know and that rank in the top 1,000,000 and so on.
• Whereas 4.7% of all websites use Java
• Java is used in 4.8% of all the websites that rank in the top 1,000,000 nd it continues in the same way.

This brings us to the end of the .Net and Java comparison. Now that you have an idea about what are the differences in .NET vs Java. Let’s move forward and see when it is better to use .NET over Java and vice versa.

.NET Vs JAVA: Which Is Better?

After going through the difference between the two technologies, let’s find out which one is better while comparing them.

When to use JAVA over .NET

• Java is a free and open-source programming language.
• It has a more significant development community, which means more help forums and documentation.
• Java’s IDEs have more plugins, which saves a lot of time during development.
• JVM (Java, Scala, Clojure, and other languages) is considerably more widely used.
• Exceptions in Java are more manageable.
• Java competes with IoT by providing extensive libraries for developing embedded apps.
• Java is great for developing error-free enterprise software because it has a mature and tight structure and performs run-time checks.

When to use .NET over JAVA

• .NET Framework is ideal for creating Windows-specific systems
• Allows developers to collaborate on the same project using different languages (C#, VB.NET, and C++)
• Debugging is a breeze with .NET
• The deployment of .NET apps are swift and effortless
• The implementation of Ajax is basic and straightforward
• .NET is fantastic for creating user interfaces
• Azure is Microsoft’s cloud IoT and Big Data platform

How to choose between .NET vs JAVA

• When deciding between these two technologies, the primary consideration should be availability. It’s more difficult to find .NET developers than it is to find Java developers. You should also consider the infrastructure you have available to support the website or app you’re creating with .NET.
• It is a widely held belief that .NET is better suited to developing enterprise-level applications when it comes to open-source compatibility, Java outperforms .NET in terms of interoperability.
• As more businesses use open-source solutions, Java has surpassed .NET in popularity. However, it’s worth noting that Microsoft is attempting to close the gap by integrating with other open-source alternatives.
• Another consideration while deciding between the two is the expense. If you’re going to use Windows-based solutions and other Microsoft products, .NET is the way to go. If you choose Java, though, you’ll need to figure out what additional tools you’ll need for your project.

Where to use Java

Java is a general-purpose programming language, which implies it may be used in a variety of fields:

• Android Applications
• Enterprise Applications (widely used in government and consequently on modern applications like Pinterest & Spotify)
• Web Applications (Google Docs, Gmail)
• Softwares (Eclipse, Jira)
• Embedded system

Where to use .NET

Also Check – Top Java Frameworks to Use in 2023

Companies using .NET And JAVA

Final Decision : .NET vs JAVA

To summarize, .NET and JAVA are not mutually exclusive. Because both platforms offer nearly identical functionality and target the same market, it all comes down to dedicated developer abilities, underlying infrastructure, interoperability needs, and end-user environments.

Both technologies are helpful for major enterprise-level projects and have comparable applications. Although Java offers a larger community, more documentation, a larger skill pool, and more career opportunities, .NET performs better and includes tools for complicated user interfaces.

Still having trouble deciding which technology is appropriate for your project?. Book a free consultation with our experts, ensuring that you are directed in the appropriate direction and that your project is taken care of.